Full-Service vs Budget Airlines: Hidden Costs

Explore the hidden costs of budget vs full-service airlines and learn how to calculate your true travel expenses for smarter flying.

Flying budget airlines might seem cheap at first glance, but hidden fees can quickly inflate your total cost. From baggage and seat selection charges to booking and food fees, these extras can make a $49 ticket cost more than $200. Full-service airlines, on the other hand, offer higher upfront fares that often include these amenities, resulting in fewer surprises. Here's what you need to know:

  • Budget Airlines: Low base fares but charge for nearly everything - carry-ons, seat selection, and even booking fees. For example, a $90 Spirit Airlines ticket can jump to over $220 after extras.
  • Full-Service Airlines: Higher base fares but include essentials like baggage, seat selection, and meals. A $180 American Airlines ticket often covers what budget carriers charge extra for.
  • Key Costs to Watch:
    • Carry-on fees: $20–$89
    • Checked bags: $35–$65 (higher for overweight/oversized)
    • Seat selection: $5–$100+
    • Booking fees: Up to $23

Quick Tip: Budget airlines work best for short trips with minimal luggage, while full-service carriers often save money for longer flights or when traveling with extras. Always calculate the total cost before booking to avoid surprises.

Full-service vs low-cost airlines

Budget vs Full-Service Airlines: How Each Pricing Model Works

Airline pricing can be tricky - what starts as a $49 ticket often balloons into something much higher. The way airlines structure their prices plays a huge role in this. Budget and full-service airlines take very different approaches, and understanding these models can help you spot the hidden fees that might inflate your travel costs.

Budget Airlines: Pay-Per-Service Model

Budget airlines operate on a "pay only for what you use" model. The base fare covers just your seat, and just about everything else - carry-on bags, seat selection, snacks - comes with an extra charge. This lets them advertise incredibly low fares, but the final cost can climb quickly.

For example, a carry-on bag might cost anywhere from $30 to $89. Want to pick your seat? That could add $5 to $100 or more. Even booking your ticket online isn’t always free - some airlines, like Allegiant, tack on an $18 "Electronic Carrier Usage Charge" on top of the base fare. These fees often increase if you wait to add them later.

Budget airlines also sell tickets almost exclusively through their own websites. This helps them control the booking process and maximize opportunities to add fees. By the time you've paid for all the essentials, that bargain ticket may end up costing as much as - or more than - a full-service airline.

Full-Service Airlines: All-Inclusive Pricing

Full-service airlines take a different approach by bundling most amenities into the ticket price. While their base fares are typically higher, they include many of the services that budget airlines charge for separately. A full-service ticket usually covers checked baggage, seat selection, in-flight meals, snacks, drinks, and entertainment. Some airlines even go further, offering perks like lounge access or generous frequent flyer benefits. For example, Southwest allows two checked bags for free, which can save families a lot of money.

This bundled model means fewer surprises when booking. While you might pay extra for premium seats or additional baggage, the core travel experience is already included in the advertised price. These costs tend to be more predictable compared to the piecemeal charges of budget airlines.

Full-service carriers also distribute tickets through multiple channels, such as travel agents, comparison websites, and their own platforms. This broader access often makes it easier to compare prices and get a clearer picture of your total travel costs.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how these two pricing models stack up:

Pricing Model Base Fare Included Services Common Extra Fees
Budget Airlines Very Low ($49–$99) Seat only Baggage ($30–$89), Seat selection ($5–$100+), Food ($5–$15), Booking fees ($18–$23)
Full-Service Higher ($120–$300) Checked bag, meals, entertainment, seat selection Premium seats ($50–$319), Extra bags ($35–$40), Upgrades

The main difference boils down to transparency and predictability. Budget airlines attract travelers with low fares but often pile on fees, while full-service airlines offer higher upfront prices that cover most essentials. For Dallas travelers using Joe's Flights alerts, understanding these models can help you decide whether those $79 flights to Los Angeles or $89 tickets to New York are truly a bargain once all the extras are factored in. Up next, we’ll dive into the specific fees that can turn a cheap flight into an expensive one.

Hidden Fees You Need to Watch For

After breaking down pricing models, it’s time to dive into hidden fees that can quietly balloon your travel expenses. These fees are a major profit source for airlines, and if you’re not careful, they can derail your travel budget in no time.

Baggage Fees

Baggage fees are often a rude awakening for travelers, especially families. Budget airlines like Spirit and Frontier charge for both carry-on and checked bags, while many full-service airlines still include at least one carry-on for free.

For budget carriers, carry-on fees can range from $20 to over $60. Spirit Airlines, for instance, charges as much as $89 depending on when you book. On the other hand, airlines like Delta, United, and American generally allow one free carry-on bag, though basic economy fares may have restrictions.

Checked bag fees are climbing across the board. Most major U.S. airlines now charge $35–$40 for the first checked bag, up from about $30 last year. Budget airlines charge around $30–$35 if you pay online, but those fees can spike to $65 at the airport. Overweight or oversized bags? Prepare to shell out $138 or more per bag.

Southwest Airlines remains the exception, offering two free checked bags for all passengers. Many full-service airlines also include at least one free checked bag with standard tickets. But when you add in seat selection costs, your ticket price can rise even further.

Seat Selection Fees

If you’re hoping to avoid the dreaded middle seat or sit together as a family, brace yourself for extra charges on budget airlines. Standard seat selection fees range from $5 to $25 when booked ahead, but during peak times or last-minute bookings, they can soar past $100.

Premium seats with extra legroom are even pricier. Spirit and Frontier often charge $25 to $100 per segment for preferred or exit row seats. Full-service airlines, in contrast, typically allow free standard seat selection (except for basic economy tickets), with premium seats costing between $140 and $319 per segment.

These costs can add up fast. For a family of four trying to sit together and avoid middle seats, you might spend an extra $50 to $200 on a budget airline. Meanwhile, full-service carriers often include this perk at little to no additional cost. And seat selection isn’t the only surprise waiting in the booking process.

Booking and Payment Fees

Budget airlines are notorious for sneaking in fees during the booking process. For example:

  • Spirit Airlines charges a "Passenger Usage Charge" of up to $22.99 each way.
  • Frontier Airlines adds a "Carrier Interface Charge" ranging from $4 to $21 each way.
  • Allegiant Air tacks on an "Electronic Carrier Usage Charge" of $18 each way.

If you book over the phone, expect to pay up to $25 per ticket. Some airlines even charge extra fees for credit card payments. Need to make changes to your booking? That could cost $75 to $200 per ticket on budget carriers, with cancellation fees just as steep. Full-service airlines tend to have clearer fee structures and may waive change or cancellation fees for certain fares or elite members.

Food, Drinks, and In-Flight Services

On budget airlines, buying food and drinks can feel like shopping at a pricey convenience store. A basic sandwich might set you back $10–$20, a soda around $5, and snacks between $5 and $15. For a family on a longer flight, these costs can easily climb to $50–$80.

Full-service airlines generally include complimentary snacks and non-alcoholic drinks, with meals provided on longer flights. They also offer free in-flight entertainment, such as seatback screens or streaming options. In contrast, budget airlines often charge for Wi-Fi and entertainment or provide limited options.

Studies show that passengers on budget airlines often end up spending far more than the advertised base fare. For instance, a $100 base fare can quickly balloon to $250–$300 once you factor in baggage, seat selection, and food costs. Meanwhile, a full-service carrier’s $180 fare might include many of these extras, keeping your total closer to the initial price.

For those in Dallas using Joe’s Flights alerts, understanding these fee structures is key. That $79 flight to Los Angeles or $89 ticket to New York might not be such a bargain once you account for the real cost of flying.

Total Cost Examples: Budget vs Full-Service Airlines

When it comes to air travel, hidden fees can completely change the picture. Let’s compare how total costs stack up between budget and full-service airlines, using a Dallas-to-New York one-way flight as an example.

Side-by-Side Cost Breakdowns

Here’s a look at what you might actually pay when all the extras are factored in:

Cost Component Spirit Airlines (Budget) American Airlines (Full-Service)
Base fare $90 $180
Carry-on bag $35 Included
Checked bag $40 Included
Seat selection $25 Included
Booking fee $22.99 None
Food/drink $10 Included
Total Cost $222.99 $180

That $90 base fare on Spirit quickly balloons to $222.99 once you add in the typical extras, while American Airlines’ $180 ticket already includes those services.

For other budget airlines, a $50 fare can climb to around $418 with add-ons, compared to $200–$250 for similar full-service flights. For families, a budget airline’s $200 base fare might end up exceeding $800 after extras, while a full-service carrier might cost closer to $600. These examples highlight when budget airlines might actually cost more than their full-service counterparts.

When Budget Airlines Save You Money

Budget airlines can save you money, but only under specific circumstances - like traveling light and skipping the extras. For short trips where you can pack everything into a small personal item that fits under the seat, budget carriers shine. For instance, a Dallas-to-Houston flight with just a backpack might cost only the base fare of $50–$90, far cheaper than the $150–$200 full-service ticket for the same route.

Solo travelers, especially those on quick business trips, can also benefit. If you’re sticking to the basics, you could save $50 to $100 per trip. For Dallas flyers keeping an eye on Joe’s Flights deals, those $79 fares to Los Angeles or $89 tickets to New York can be genuine bargains - if you avoid the add-ons.

When Full-Service Airlines Cost Less Overall

Full-service airlines often win out when you need multiple services, like checked bags, assigned seating, or in-flight meals. The add-ons that budget carriers charge for can make their fares up to 40% more expensive in the end.

Longer flights tend to tip the scales even further. For example, on a Dallas-to-Seattle route, extras like baggage, seat selection, and meals can add $100–$150 to a budget airline fare. These costs are typically included in the price of a full-service ticket.

Business travelers also see value in full-service airlines. When you add up the extras, the more predictable pricing of carriers like American or Delta often makes them the better overall deal.

Here’s some data to back it up: Alaska Airlines adds about 105% to its base fare through fees, Frontier adds a whopping 376%, and Spirit tops the chart with a staggering 736% increase. With such extreme fee multipliers, that initially higher full-service fare can actually save you money in the long run.

For Dallas travelers monitoring Joe’s Flights deals, these comparisons make it easier to see the true cost of flying.

How to Calculate Your Real Flight Cost

When booking a flight, the advertised fare often tells only part of the story. On average, U.S. airlines tack on an extra $78.04 per ticket in additional fees, and budget carriers can significantly inflate the base fare with a range of charges. To uncover what you’ll actually pay, a detailed approach is essential.

Complete Fee Checklist

Start by noting the base fare and then factor in all potential extras. Baggage fees alone can range from $35 to $90, with overweight luggage adding anywhere from $100 to $450. Don’t forget carry-on fees if you’re flying a budget airline - these typically cost $20–$30 when booked ahead but can climb to $60 at the airport.

Seat selection fees are another variable expense. A basic seat assignment might cost as little as $5, but premium options - like extra legroom - can exceed $100, with some reaching as high as $319. Payment and booking fees can add up to $22.99, and don’t assume food and drinks are included; those often come with an added cost. Finally, federal taxes must be accounted for.

Fee structures can vary widely, adding complexity to the calculation. For instance, Frontier Airlines charges anywhere from $0 to $138 for the first checked bag, depending on the route and demand. By reviewing the specific fees tied to your flight, you’ll avoid being misled by a low base fare and get a clearer picture of the total cost.

Flight Comparison Tools That Show Total Costs

Thankfully, modern flight comparison tools make it easier to see beyond the base fare. Many platforms now allow you to input preferences - like baggage needs or seat selection - to calculate the real total in real time. This way, you won’t find yourself comparing a $90 Spirit Airlines ticket to a $180 full-service fare without understanding the full breakdown.

Look for tools that aggregate fares across airlines and display required taxes alongside typical add-ons. Some even let you filter by total cost, including extras like checked baggage or specific seat types. These features help you identify genuine deals while avoiding flights that look cheap but are loaded with hidden fees. After using your checklist to determine your needs, these tools can make the search process more efficient.

U.S. Fee Disclosure Rules

To protect consumers, the U.S. Department of Transportation requires airlines to disclose extra fees upfront during the booking process. This includes charges for checked and carry-on baggage, as well as fees for changes or cancellations. Airlines must show these costs alongside the base fare and schedule details, instead of burying them in hyperlinks.

Additionally, airlines must provide personalized fee information if you qualify for discounts through loyalty programs, military status, or certain credit cards. According to DOT estimates, these transparency measures save U.S. travelers over $500 million annually by reducing unnecessary fees.

However, it’s worth noting that these rules only apply to mandatory charges and common extras. Optional services - like priority boarding, Wi-Fi, or premium meals - may still appear later in the booking process.

For those flying out of Dallas, Joe’s Flights simplifies this process. By tracking fares from both DFW and Love Field, they alert you to real price drops and include essential booking details, helping you separate true bargains from flights riddled with hidden costs.

The takeaway? A staggering 89% of airlines try to upsell during the booking process. With a thorough fee checklist, smart comparison tools, and a solid understanding of U.S. disclosure rules, you can calculate your actual flight cost and make well-informed choices that save you money.

Choosing the Right Airline for Your Trip

Once you’ve figured out how to calculate real flight costs, the next step is picking the airline that fits your travel needs. Hidden fees can turn a $100 ticket into a $250–$300 expense, so it’s crucial to align your priorities with the right pricing model - and know how to spot true value.

Budget vs. Full-Service: What to Keep in Mind

When deciding between budget and full-service airlines, it’s not just about the ticket price. Here are some key factors to consider:

  • Always calculate the total cost - not just the base fare. Budget airlines often tack on fees that can increase your expenses by up to 40% more than expected. For example, U.S. airlines add an average of $78.04 in fees per ticket. That $90 fare on Spirit Airlines? It could easily end up costing as much as a full-service airline ticket once you add baggage fees, seat selection, and other charges. If you’re traveling light on a short, direct flight, budget airlines might work. But for families or long-haul trips, full-service carriers often provide better overall value.
  • Factor in hidden inconveniences. Budget airlines may save you money upfront, but navigating their fee structures and dealing with limited flexibility can cost you time and peace of mind. Sometimes paying a bit more for an all-inclusive fare is worth it.
  • Use flight comparison tools that show total costs. Since 89% of airlines try to upsell during the booking process, having a clear view of the full price - including fees - can help you avoid surprise expenses. A fee checklist can also keep you from making impulse purchases that inflate your total cost.

How Joe's Flights Helps Dallas Travelers Save

Joe's Flights

For travelers in Dallas, Joe's Flights takes the hassle out of finding great deals. By monitoring fares from both DFW and Love Field, this service identifies genuine price drops, so you don’t have to stress over picking between budget and full-service airlines.

Joe's Flights has uncovered deals like $79 flights to LA and $89 tickets to NYC, proving that error fares and special promotions can offer big savings, no matter the airline type. Their system tracks price fluctuations and sends alerts when fares drop significantly, along with all the details you need to book quickly.

This is especially helpful for catching those limited-time deals where timing is everything. While you’re busy calculating baggage fees or seat charges, Joe's Flights is already on top of fare changes, ensuring you don’t miss out on real savings.

The takeaway? Focus on overall value rather than getting stuck on airline categories. Choose the option that best fits your budget, service expectations, and convenience needs - and let Joe's Flights help you find those opportunities.

FAQs

How can I figure out the total cost of a flight with a budget airline and avoid hidden fees?

When booking a flight with a budget airline, it’s important to factor in all potential costs before finalizing your purchase. These airlines often charge extra for things like choosing your seat, checking bags, bringing carry-ons, and even basic amenities like snacks or drinks during the flight.

Take some time to carefully read the terms and conditions and think about what services you’ll actually need. For instance, if you plan to check a bag, weigh the airline’s baggage fees against the savings on the ticket price. By adding up these extra charges, you’ll have a clearer idea of the total cost, helping you avoid any unexpected expenses at checkout or when you arrive at the airport.

What are the main differences in pricing and services between budget and full-service airlines?

Budget airlines are popular for their low base ticket prices, but keep in mind that extras like checked bags, seat selection, and even in-flight snacks often come with additional fees. In contrast, full-service airlines usually bundle these perks into the ticket price, offering a more inclusive travel experience.

For travelers flying out of Dallas airports - DFW or Love Field - keeping an eye on price drops can be a smart way to find affordable flights and steer clear of surprise expenses.

When can flying with budget airlines save you money compared to full-service airlines?

Budget airlines can be a great way to save money, especially if you’re traveling light and don’t need extras like checked bags, assigned seats, or in-flight meals. Their lower base fares make them an attractive option for short trips or when you don’t need much flexibility.

However, to truly save, you’ll need to pay close attention to their fees for add-ons. Costs like baggage fees or charges for changing your booking can pile up quickly, eating into those savings. If you plan ahead and stick to just the essentials, you can often make the most of the low fares offered by budget carriers.

Related Blog Posts

Ready to see your first deal?

Drop your email below and let’s get you flying cheaper out of Dallas.

Please click the link in the email to confirm your email address and you'll be receiving deals in no time!

Make sure to check your spam folder.
Well, this is awkward. Something broke. Email us: help@joesflights.com

Free to join. Cheaper than your airport coffee.